Sunday, November 22, 2026

125. Wedding Present - Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now? (Reception)




Four weeks at number one from 4th October 1988


The first woman I fell in love with (or at least, the first woman I thought I loved) was cursed with the communication skills of a jellyfish*. This is an admittedly harsh way of putting it, so I should take this opportunity to gently clarify the facts; her prime motivations in life, so far as I could initially tell, were to be kind, amenable and liked by as many people as possible. It was adorable when we were friends, and a big part of the reason why I became besotted with her. If you were aiming to be in a relationship with her, however, things were tough, because all was not as it immediately seemed. 

Everybody has been out with somebody like this at one point or another; the smiley, quiet, graceful people pleaser who to your amazement, moodily tells you two months after a date (and not before) that actually, it was a drag, and they were only coming along to make you happy, or actually, you should have known from the fact that their smile was 2% tighter than normal that they didn’t enjoy spending time with your friend and his partner a month ago, so you shouldn’t have arranged it again. On one occasion, very close to the point before she dumped me, I found myself saying “You should have told me. I don’t understand why you didn’t TELL me!” To my shame, I realised a few minutes later that I was just quoting this song (and that alone should have been reason enough to get the boot).

Whatever you think of David Gedge’s work, he has an almost comedically astute sense for the dynamics of failing relationships; had he not made a modest success of being an indie star, I have to wonder whether he might have been able to move into relationship counselling instead. “Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now” has less of a narrative than their previous indie number ones, and almost feels like a series of spiky mid-argument complaints, barked and left to hang in the air. “Do I have to guess how you're going to feel each day” competes with “No one can change that much in three days” and “You've never mentioned this before”, all high in the chart of “exasperated lines we’ve all used in real life when our relationships are struggling”.

The final line, repeated incessantly, is so hilarious it could almost have been written for a Half Man Half Biscuit song. After the song’s title is repeated for the final time, Gedge moans “Oh… how could you do this to me?” If you’re in the middle of a break-up, somebody’s meek reasonableness can feel like the biggest punishment of all – all those months of agony and sniping comments about failed mind-reading peaking with the dumpee putting on their gentle, kindly face again; the face you fell for to begin with. As it all began, so it must cruelly end. In certain circumstances, reasonableness can feel like the hottest knife of all.

This single ended up becoming a popular favourite with fans, reaching number 8 in John Peel’s Festive Fifty that year, and has persistently received favourable comments online. Despite this, and despite my feelings on how relatable the subject matter is, I’m afraid it’s not something I want to hear very often. Melodically speaking, there’s a serious lack of either hooks or lingering tension in this one. The Weddoes are at their absolute best when they come up with an aggressive, stabbing riff (“Brassneck”, “Anyone Can Make A Mistake”) an almost poppy chorus (“Nobody’s Twisting Your Arm”) or a soaring, repetitive finale (“Kennedy”, “My Favourite Dress”). “Reasonable” just sulkily kicks along, spraying leaves in the middle of the path and never truly finding any jewels beneath them. It’s relatively memorable, but also somewhat middling and muted; never truly growing teeth or tickling neglected parts of your brain with its melodies.

As such, I don’t pull it out to play very often, but for those who love back-catalogue curios, it’s of worth for two reasons – firstly, it was a stand-alone single which never found any place on a subsequent studio album. Secondly, a French language version was released (“Pourquoi Es Tu Devenue Si Raisonnable?”) which treats listeners to Gedge barking the song with his Yorkshire accent partially intact. God alone knows what the French fans made of it – the one fluent French-speaking friend I had at the time informed me that it was “hilariously bad”.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

124. Bomb The Bass - Megablast/ Don't Make Me Wait (Rhythm King)


 














One week at number one on 24th September 1988


As 1988 progressed, all the break-out House music stars were faced with a decision – should they cling to the same scattershot formula for the follow-up to their hit, or prove there was more to their work than a being a knowledgeable chef with a huge pantry and speedy chopping skills?

Mark Moore clearly decided that what wasn’t broken shouldn’t be meddled with, and “Superfly Guy” continued the messy thrills. Coldcut went off on a strange reggae safari with “Stop This Crazy Thing”, which bore as much relation to “Doctorin’ The House” as a giraffe does to a lion, and Bomb The Bass? Tim Simenon indulged in an interesting bit of cake-ism by doing both things at once.

Their second indie number one was therefore this; a double A-side which, in many chart listings, put “Megablast” in prime position, even though the track didn’t seem to have a promotional video (please do correct me if I’m wrong) and was almost never heard on the radio or television. Here’s where we get the continuity “Beat Dis” approach. “Megablast” is another bass heavy juggernaut ploughing through your neighbourhood, all barked samples, juddering rhythms, clarion call melodies and a faintly basic, lo-fi production.

While the samples are almost as fast and furious as “Beat Dis” – Freda Payne, Sly and the Family Stone, Rufus Thomas, Malcolm McLaren, Pink Floyd and the Apocalypse Now soundtrack all make their presence felt – it contains something which is much closer to a melodic hook than their first hit, namely that cheery, celebratory keyboard riff which emerges at regular intervals. As such, it’s less interesting somehow, less of a volatile stew of mixed ingredients and more of a standard dance track with a central gravitational catchphrase bidding for airplay. The bassline is strangely bare too, like a Commodore 64’s SID chip stretching towards distortion (though this may seem very appealing to some retro 8 bit loving listeners in the 21st Century).

Then, over on the other side – the side radio and television actually exposed us to – lay “Don’t Make Me Wait”, featuring Lorraine (aka Cool Notes member Laurine McIntosh). It’s a different concoction altogether, being more straightforwardly Pop than anything Simenon’s rivals had produced prior to this; in fact, the robotic exhortations to move one’s body, Lorraine’s bright vocals and the synth stabs and jerky but deliberately hooky keyboard melodies are attention-grabbing in traditional, almost Pete Waterman-approved ways. It’s only the glitchiness of the House rhythms beneath that give the track a credible clubland groove – in all other respects, it adheres to pop music’s strict rules about verses, choruses and middle eights. We wouldn’t have banked on this a few months before.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

123. House of Love - Destroy The Heart (Creation)



Four weeks at number one from 27th August 1988


Strange things were brewing in the Creation Records offices in 1988. For one thing, Commander McGee had, along with a significant swathe of the British population, got into House music. According to the marvellous book "My Magpie Eyes Are Hungry For The Prize", he could be found in clubs in London and Brighton, happily swirling around to the latest sounds while under the influence of mountains of delicious ecstasy.

Accompanying him would be a gentleman who always took his clothes off at the height of his high, “dancing like ET” afterwards. That man was Guy Chadwick, the lead singer of the House of Love, a group by now widely tipped to be the future of rock music; if not the next Smiths, with whom they had little in common, then perhaps the next U2.

There are numerous unexpected contradictions in the above. Chadwick’s group never went near drum machines and samplers, yet there he was, dancing badly to everyone who did. Creation Records also really hadn’t delved into House music much yet, though their time would come. This odd schism paints a fair picture of the state of alternative rock in 1988; while to a casual reader in 2026 it may seem strange to have so many House records dominating the indie listings, at the time it felt logical and wonderful. That was where the revolution was occurring and the fresh, exciting sounds were emerging from. Some alternative rock musicians, from Jaz Coleman to Miles Hunt, may have mithered on about how House Music wasn’t “proper music” and lacked the integrity and passion of rock, but they frankly sounded ridiculous in the process – like a bunch of proggers witlessly complaining about the lack of craft to be found in punk. "If we should be listening to you instead, come up with some fresh ideas and make us want to, you nitwits", you couldn't help but think. 

This environment created an awkward situation if you were in a straightforward alternative rock band. Music journalists began the year wondering who would replace the dearly departed Smiths, and ended it no longer really caring. Record Mirror even changed its editorial focus to mostly specialise in Dance music, often treating Indie as something to be ghettoised in its own two-page news section. Outside the shadowy corners of the Goth scene, it also seemed as if not much was going on which would result in new stars. Except, that is, for the House of Love.

By 1988, the major labels were watching the group, enabling Alan McGee to stay at the Savoy Hotel in London and invite A&R representatives in, one after the other, to pitch their six-figure advance offers. A frenzy ensued which ultimately resulted in the group being sold to David Bates at Fontana Records, but amidst the confusion at least one other label entered the fray who seemed to have mistaken them for another band entirely, nearly putting a huge bid down for something they didn’t actually want. Such things happen when hysteria is allowed to take hold.

Record company frenzies are rarely forged from complete mediocrity, however, and while the group had very little obvious competition in 1988 (huge emphasis on “obvious” here) they were still responsible for a string of singles which were mysterious, touching, and enormous sounding without once being pompous. Their single “Christine” is a prime example of this, a track which seemed to stare down at you from an enormous plinth yet still somehow sounded fragile and brittle, avoiding all the stadium cliches for something which alternately jangled earthily, then scraped the sky with its airy, whitewashed chorus.

Guy Chadwick may have written all their songs, but to most people it was obvious that there was another key figure in the group. Terry Bickers, the lead guitarist, took his songs and smeared paint all over them, amping them up from moody Leonard Cohen influenced laments into something much more colourful and unpredictable. “Destroy The Heart” is a primary example of this. Lyrically it’s frequently nondescript, with Chadwick merely offering a series of frustrated complaints about the romantic expectations of ladies he’d loved and lost, but those matter-of-fact late night regrets are picked up and carved into strange new shapes by Bickers. In much the same way Syd Barrett took Richard Wright’s blank, rueful prose about a lost childhood in “Remember A Day” and made it squawk, swoop and wail, Bickers slams his guitar and makes it squeal against Chadwick’s monotone, adding sprays of powdered pastel colour to a dark backdrop. The song is transformed from a groaning ballad into something much more dramatic, desperate even.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

122. Yazz & The Plastic Population - The Only Way Is Up (Big Life)




One week at number one on 20th August 1988


Originally, I was tempted to tie this together with the last entry (“Superfly Guy”) for the simple reason that it underlines the point I was making about the different approaches to music for the dancefloor. You can either stick doggedly to a groove where the lyrics are a pure afterthought, mere chanted exhortations, or offer a much more coherent, emotional story, guided more by pop song structures (“I Will Survive”).

Otis Clay’s original version of “The Only Way Is Up” was always on the latter side of the fence, though wasn’t a huge success when released in 1982. If you haven’t listened to it in a while, go back and do so again – while researching this entry, I found myself unexpectedly moved by having the experience afresh. I’d forgotten just how understated it was, yet personal. If you’ve ever experienced poverty, however briefly, the idea of having somebody by your side throughout the ordeal takes on a highly romantic edge; a lot of couples don’t make it through to the other side as desperate times expose ugly personality flaws. We may all have insecurities about not being attractive enough, clever enough, charismatic enough or warm enough for our partners, but capable enough? Able to actually contribute towards food and shelter, fundamental life basics? Not being a financial drag? In the unforgiving modern world, that’s a kicker, and something the post-Reagan/Thatcher mainstream continually reinforces as a kind of societal blight.  

Literal hunger can also lead to brash comments, rash behaviour and long solo walks in the freezing cold away from the claustrophobia of the bedsit. The very idea of a couple helping each other through the dark times, convinced that better things are ahead, is therefore an extremely strange idea for a dancefloor driven ballad, but an effective and touching one – and the songwriters Jackson and Henderson pull no punches (“If we should be evicted from our homes” is a brutal line in any context) while Clay sells it subtly and beautifully, without a hint of bitterness, like a warm hug in a freezing cold bed. When he sings “I know love will see us through” (a line missing from Yazz’s version) he could be singing about a relationship or about society more generally, depending on how you want to hear it. It feels like underclass gospel.

In some senses, Yazz may have seemed like the perfect person to front a cover of this record. She was sold to the public as a plucky everywoman, a club dancefloor girl with a distinctive peroxide crop who got lucky. On her first chart appearance with “Doctorin’ The House” she played an important part, providing a clarion call and foundation to Coldcut’s chaotic pilfering of old records, but it was certainly more their track than hers. A lot of people assumed she was a friend of the duo, grabbed from the club floor, when in reality she had already spent some time working as a catwalk model, and was shortly afterwards handled by Wham!’s management team. They sent her to singing lessons and she cut a demo, then was subsequently introduced to Coldcut, who happened to issue “Doctorin’ The House” right at the point where House music was becoming a commercial force (their previous records had not charted).

Her version of “The Only Way Is Up”, produced by Coldcut again, is fascinating to listen to back-to-back with Clay’s, purely because the approach is so different. Clay is smooth and warm but dogged, doing his best for his partner and guardian angel. Yazz, on the other hand, is being driven by something else – a noisy self-belief almost. Her delivery suggests she’s never lost a minute’s sleep in her life wondering if she’s wrong, or feeling as if actually, her natural level in life might be working in a call centre. The track is far too ebullient for that, punctuated with screams of victory and joy. You exit Clay’s track thinking he might land himself a perfectly average job soon, whereas throughout, Yazz sounds as if she’s already won the lottery (and in a funny way, of course, she had).

You could meaningfully compare “The Only Way Is Up” to “I Will Survive”. While Gaynor’s single is about surviving without your deadbeat cheating lover, “Up” is about the pair of you surviving through the difficulties – in Yazz’s hands, it’s a tool of absolute defiance and self-belief, determination winning over any scrap of self-doubt. Just as Gaynor knows she can get by alone, Yazz also knows that two good people united in determination to overcome their difficulties are going to have better odds than one.

Her ecstatic (pun absolutely intended) delivery is also much more in keeping with the dancefloor of the day. Coldcut’s trumpet howls, jittery bottle-bank rhythms and squelching Acid sounds demand something that can overpower them rather than falling beneath them, and just as she did on “Doctorin’ The House”, Yazz rises to the occasion. At moments, she howls in what can only be described as joyous defiance, and it sounds like an unbelievably of-the-moment record – skint kids at Shoom, being part of a movement, a moment, dosed up on E and believing that despite all the difficulties, they are finally part of something together (cue one of Mike Skinner’s diatribes). She effectively took this song away from the early eighties global recession and translated it for the later, chemical part of the decade.