
Four weeks at number one from 4th October 1988
The first woman I fell in love with (or at least, the first woman I thought I loved) was cursed with the communication skills of a jellyfish*. This is an admittedly harsh way of putting it, so I should take this opportunity to gently clarify the facts; her prime motivations in life, so far as I could initially tell, were to be kind, amenable and liked by as many people as possible. It was adorable when we were friends, and a big part of the reason why I became besotted with her. If you were aiming to be in a relationship with her, however, things were tough, because all was not as it immediately seemed.
Everybody has been out with somebody like this at one point or another; the smiley, quiet, graceful people pleaser who to your amazement, moodily tells you two months after a date (and not before) that actually, it was a drag, and they were only coming along to make you happy, or actually, you should have known from the fact that their smile was 2% tighter than normal that they didn’t enjoy spending time with your friend and his partner a month ago, so you shouldn’t have arranged it again. On one occasion, very close to the point before she dumped me, I found myself saying “You should have told me. I don’t understand why you didn’t TELL me!” To my shame, I realised a few minutes later that I was just quoting this song (and that alone should have been reason enough to get the boot).
Whatever you think of David Gedge’s work, he has an almost comedically astute sense for the dynamics of failing relationships; had he not made a modest success of being an indie star, I have to wonder whether he might have been able to move into relationship counselling instead. “Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now” has less of a narrative than their previous indie number ones, and almost feels like a series of spiky mid-argument complaints, barked and left to hang in the air. “Do I have to guess how you're going to feel each day” competes with “No one can change that much in three days” and “You've never mentioned this before”, all high in the chart of “exasperated lines we’ve all used in real life when our relationships are struggling”.
The final line, repeated incessantly, is so hilarious it could almost have been written for a Half Man Half Biscuit song. After the song’s title is repeated for the final time, Gedge moans “Oh… how could you do this to me?” If you’re in the middle of a break-up, somebody’s meek reasonableness can feel like the biggest punishment of all – all those months of agony and sniping comments about failed mind-reading peaking with the dumpee putting on their gentle, kindly face again; the face you fell for to begin with. As it all began, so it must cruelly end. In certain circumstances, reasonableness can feel like the hottest knife of all.
This single ended up becoming a popular favourite with fans, reaching number 8 in John Peel’s Festive Fifty that year, and has persistently received favourable comments online. Despite this, and despite my feelings on how relatable the subject matter is, I’m afraid it’s not something I want to hear very often. Melodically speaking, there’s a serious lack of either hooks or lingering tension in this one. The Weddoes are at their absolute best when they come up with an aggressive, stabbing riff (“Brassneck”, “Anyone Can Make A Mistake”) an almost poppy chorus (“Nobody’s Twisting Your Arm”) or a soaring, repetitive finale (“Kennedy”, “My Favourite Dress”). “Reasonable” just sulkily kicks along, spraying leaves in the middle of the path and never truly finding any jewels beneath them. It’s relatively memorable, but also somewhat middling and muted; never truly growing teeth or tickling neglected parts of your brain with its melodies.
As such, I don’t pull it out to play very often, but for those who love back-catalogue curios, it’s of worth for two reasons – firstly, it was a stand-alone single which never found any place on a subsequent studio album. Secondly, a French language version was released (“Pourquoi Es Tu Devenue Si Raisonnable?”) which treats listeners to Gedge barking the song with his Yorkshire accent partially intact. God alone knows what the French fans made of it – the one fluent French-speaking friend I had at the time informed me that it was “hilariously bad”.
All this helped to push the group towards the brink of the National Top 40 for a second time, and RCA dived in once again to remove another group from the indie sector and into their glacial corporate offices. The Wedding Present’s experiences on a major label were perhaps slightly less tense than Pop Will Eat Itself’s, but when Gedge embarked on his plans to release a new single every month in 1992, he found his requests reluctantly honoured with much carping and sighing. “There’s no way we can turn a profit from this project,” whined an employee of the label, while Gedge tried to politely point out ways his own Reception label would easily have spun cash from it.
Whatever you think of David Gedge’s work, he has an almost comedically astute sense for the dynamics of failing relationships; had he not made a modest success of being an indie star, I have to wonder whether he might have been able to move into relationship counselling instead. “Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now” has less of a narrative than their previous indie number ones, and almost feels like a series of spiky mid-argument complaints, barked and left to hang in the air. “Do I have to guess how you're going to feel each day” competes with “No one can change that much in three days” and “You've never mentioned this before”, all high in the chart of “exasperated lines we’ve all used in real life when our relationships are struggling”.
The final line, repeated incessantly, is so hilarious it could almost have been written for a Half Man Half Biscuit song. After the song’s title is repeated for the final time, Gedge moans “Oh… how could you do this to me?” If you’re in the middle of a break-up, somebody’s meek reasonableness can feel like the biggest punishment of all – all those months of agony and sniping comments about failed mind-reading peaking with the dumpee putting on their gentle, kindly face again; the face you fell for to begin with. As it all began, so it must cruelly end. In certain circumstances, reasonableness can feel like the hottest knife of all.
This single ended up becoming a popular favourite with fans, reaching number 8 in John Peel’s Festive Fifty that year, and has persistently received favourable comments online. Despite this, and despite my feelings on how relatable the subject matter is, I’m afraid it’s not something I want to hear very often. Melodically speaking, there’s a serious lack of either hooks or lingering tension in this one. The Weddoes are at their absolute best when they come up with an aggressive, stabbing riff (“Brassneck”, “Anyone Can Make A Mistake”) an almost poppy chorus (“Nobody’s Twisting Your Arm”) or a soaring, repetitive finale (“Kennedy”, “My Favourite Dress”). “Reasonable” just sulkily kicks along, spraying leaves in the middle of the path and never truly finding any jewels beneath them. It’s relatively memorable, but also somewhat middling and muted; never truly growing teeth or tickling neglected parts of your brain with its melodies.
As such, I don’t pull it out to play very often, but for those who love back-catalogue curios, it’s of worth for two reasons – firstly, it was a stand-alone single which never found any place on a subsequent studio album. Secondly, a French language version was released (“Pourquoi Es Tu Devenue Si Raisonnable?”) which treats listeners to Gedge barking the song with his Yorkshire accent partially intact. God alone knows what the French fans made of it – the one fluent French-speaking friend I had at the time informed me that it was “hilariously bad”.
All this helped to push the group towards the brink of the National Top 40 for a second time, and RCA dived in once again to remove another group from the indie sector and into their glacial corporate offices. The Wedding Present’s experiences on a major label were perhaps slightly less tense than Pop Will Eat Itself’s, but when Gedge embarked on his plans to release a new single every month in 1992, he found his requests reluctantly honoured with much carping and sighing. “There’s no way we can turn a profit from this project,” whined an employee of the label, while Gedge tried to politely point out ways his own Reception label would easily have spun cash from it.
A good relationship of any kind, corporate or romantic, isn’t just about communication skills, then – it’s also about sharing the same reality or having a similar set of expectations. Steve Albini openly joked about Gedge’s naivete when it came to corporate culture and sure enough, before long the band were back in the indie charts again; older, wiser, and undoubtedly more weathered looking. That they continue to this day – and even repeated the “twelve singles in one year” trick in 2022 – is heartening and strangely reassuring. Seemingly not every group lies down and dies as soon as the major label money dries up.
(* If all this stuff about an ex seems a bit wrong, please be assured of several things: I haven’t named her, we fell out of touch decades ago, she almost certainly doesn’t read this blog, and she's probably a hell of a lot better at communicating her needs now, because most middle-aged adults are. Oh, and I was an even bigger nightmare to deal with. But that’s another story).
New Entries Elsewhere In The Charts
Week One
14. Jason Donovan - Nothing Can Divide Us (PWL)
Peak position: 8
The debut single of Kylie Minogue’s on-screen “Neighbours” boyfriend wasn’t surprising in itself – dragging him into the studio to sing a SAW ditty seemed downright bloody predictable months before it happened – but the half-arsed shoddiness of the end results were. “Nothing Can Divide Us” clops along like an off-the-peg synth demo, making little lasting impression, while the promo video is entirely in keeping with the indie chart in its sheer cheapness. Donovan jigs along on a podium in front of a grid of television screens like he’s doing a turn at the Building Society office party.
The lack of care and attention didn’t harm his pop prospects, though – the kids still pushed this single into the national top ten, and he would eventually become better known for his music than his acting. Notably though, “Nothing Can Divide Us” is usually only mentioned in passing whenever anyone has considered his career since.
23. Cardiacs - Suzannah's Still Alive (Alphabet)
Peak position: 16
If Blur were influenced by both The Cardiacs and The Kinks, it logically follows that The Cardiacs covering The Kinks should accidentally sound like Britpop. It doesn’t, though, and in fact it also doesn’t sound like pop of any kind. In the twisted hands of Smith and the gang, “Suzannah’s Still Alive” becomes a disjointed, piercing, gritted teeth criticism of one woman’s loneliness rather than a sad pean. Tim Smith wails some words and barks others, almost sticking the knife in.
Given that the original song was written by Dave Davies about the woman he was forcibly separated from, this version has offended some listeners (though Davies’ own opinions are, so far as I know, unrecorded). If The Cardiacs wanted to take a sixties pop tune and twist it into their world of damp-sodden derelict music halls, Ronnie Hazlehurst TV themes and overgrown children with lopsided faces, it might have been better to choose more tactfully. Despite this, though, it does work as a Cardiacs single; the group sound furious on Suzannah’s behalf, at one with her loveless neglect and oddness.
The public greeted it with less enthuasiasm than “This Is The Life”, and the group returned to their underground bunker once more.
26. Gary Numan - New Anger (Illegal)
Peak position: 22
Gary Numan’s first appearance in the NME Indie Charts. He abandoned Beggars Banquet to launch his own Numa Records label, which I covered in some depth on my old blog here – when that became a dangerous money-pit he shut up shop and found himself without a label to sit on, resulting in Miles Copeland throwing him a rope via the Illegal label.
After all that, only the most begrudging of folk would have wanted Numan to slip up, but “New Anger” sounds like a Robert Palmer inspired pop song from two years ago, released by a man whose heart isn’t entirely in it and whose fans surely can’t have wanted to hear it. It missed the National Top 40 and marked the beginning of a long spell in the doldrums for the man.
28. Close Lobsters - What Is There To Smile About? (Fire)
Peak position: 28
Week Two
18. Phuture Pfantasy Club - Slam (Low Fat Vinyl)
Peak position: 18
Aside from Psychic TV related efforts, is this the first Acid House track to breach the NME Indie Top 30? I suspect it might be. It didn’t go on to interfere with the mainstream charts, but “Slam” was nonetheless a huge draw on the dancefloor at the time, its pulsing menace turning the heads of many club-goers who were all about the plain old Vanilla flavour House a mere few months before.
19. The Flatmates - Heaven Knows (Subway)
Peak position: 10
20. Sandie Shaw - Please Help The Cause Against Loneliness (Rough Trade)
Peak position: 9
Following Sandie Shaw’s modest chart success with her cover of “Hand In Glove”, it must have seemed as if she would become a dead cert pop star all over again after being handed a fresh Morrissey track to perform. Doubtless “Top of the Pops” had her on stand-by for another performance before the single even hit the shops (meanwhile, "The Chart Show" premiered it in their Preview section weeks before release.)
The only problem is that “Please Help…” was one of the first signs that the post-Smiths Mozza wasn’t necessarily going to be firing on all cylinders at all times. The song is, lyrically speaking, rambling and garbled, trying to crowbar a bunch of seemingly unrelated Moz-isms together, and the tune itself is striving to be pop music, but is all chirp and no hook. Shaw and producer Stephen Street do their best, Sandie charismatically punching the clumsiest lines through, a chipper horn section attempting to install a sense of momentum, but it’s like trying to enter a stuffed dog on wheels into Crufts. You can jog it excitedly around the display area with a fanfare, but nobody is going to be fooled. Comparatively speaking, this would have made a second-tier Smiths B-side.
Sandie Shaw and Rough Trade’s best bet would have been to overlook the “exclusive Morrissey song” hype and lead her comeback on the marvellous “Nothing Less Than Brilliant” instead. Of course, he would never have forgiven her for that.
Still, whatever the material, Shaw remains an incredible pop star in the video below. Cute hipster women throughout the whole of the 00s were leaning on this shtick and none came close. Give her a plain white set and a few cardboard cut-outs and she had the charisma, charm and energy to give you something worth watching.
21. Red Lorry Yellow Lorry - Only Dreaming (Wide Awake) (Situation Two)
Peak position: 21
22. MDMA - Evidence (Ediesta)
Peak position: 22
The group’s name seems utterly at odds with their influences on first listen – those growling vocals and industrial drum clatters feel more in keeping with the Snakebite and Black crew than anyone popping a pill. Stick with it, though, and you eventually begin to hear aspects of the future creeping in; an urgent stammer here, a leaping keyboard trill there.
It then becomes less of a surprise to learn that MDMA featured Jez Willis and Keith Langley of Utah Saints in their line-up. “Evidence” isn’t quite pushing the envelope yet, but those little moments where the possibilities emerge are strangely tickling. A delightful culture-clash record which occasionally feels at odds with itself.
23. Laibach - Sympathy for the Devil (Mute)
Peak position: 5
Laibach generally satirised rock and roll by amping up its authoritarian aspects, picking unexpected and often well-meaning songs like “Life Is Life”, “One Vision” and even “Across The Universe” and turning them into fascist or communist anthems. “Sympathy For The Devil” seems just too damn obvious a candidate, though, and you can bet your last sticky, label faded bottle of Captain Morgan’s that Keith Richards laughed like a drain when he heard it (unlike Opus who were furious about “Life Is Life”).
Peak position: 5
Laibach generally satirised rock and roll by amping up its authoritarian aspects, picking unexpected and often well-meaning songs like “Life Is Life”, “One Vision” and even “Across The Universe” and turning them into fascist or communist anthems. “Sympathy For The Devil” seems just too damn obvious a candidate, though, and you can bet your last sticky, label faded bottle of Captain Morgan’s that Keith Richards laughed like a drain when he heard it (unlike Opus who were furious about “Life Is Life”).
25. Front 242 - Headhunter (Red Rhino)
Peak position: 12
Front 242’s debut entry here.
"Headhunter" is a very cold and threatening little single, which does have a certain nagging dancefloor action going on, but in a very rigid, staccato way, typical of the entire genre. The snarled lyrics and the sheer minimalism of the arrangement mean you're either going to respond to this with excessive enthusiasm or be left slightly cold - to me, this always felt like it wanted to be a poppier track than it actually became. The chorus almost melts into something altogether warmer and radio-friendly, before they realise how close they've come and descend into harshness again. It beckons you forward only to push you away again. It's compelling but never once feels welcoming.
Their subsequent influence on the popularity of industrial music in the UK and USA really cannot be understated, however, and they will continue to be a dominant presence in the indie chart as we go forwards.
As a bonus, this came with a rare example of Anton Corbijn being absurd with his Super 8 camera for an act who isn't Depeche Mode.
28. The Train Set - She's Gone (Play Hard)
Peak position: 27
Week Three
11. Rapeman - Budd (Blast First)
Peak position: 2
To begin by stating the obvious, the group name Rapeman caused lead protagonist Steve Albini endless grief, most notably in the UK where he was greeted with protests at gig venues from angry feminists. The name itself was derived from Japanese comic books with graphic rape scenes in them, but many politically inclined people felt, despite Albini's right-on punk credentials, that it was an insensitive and inflammatory name for a band. (My wife would like me to talk more about this, as I'm sure would some other readers. Let's just say I don't approve of the band's name and leave it at that, because there's really nothing new to add to the argument).
Many years later, of course, the song "Rape Me" by Nirvana emerged and a similar debate swelled up all over again.
Pushing all that to one side, "Bud(d)" is a complete one chord-wonder of a track which steadily builds up doom and menace. Taking quotes from the politician Budd Dwyer’s final speech, and scattering them liberally throughout the record, it's always felt like a soundtrack to him blowing his brains out in front of assembled journalists, the thudding monotony of his initial dreary and rambling speech giving way to something darker and more disturbed, dramatic and panicked.
Its huge success in the indie charts, given its minimalist approach and the controversy, always seemed unlikely. The Rapeman project was short-lived despite this, and Albini would obviously go on to become a very heavily in-demand producer and performer in Shellac, whereas Sims went on to join The Jesus Lizard.
20. M-D-Emm – Playin' With Fire (Republic)
Peak position: 19
21. Sabrina - All of Me (Boy Oh Boy) (PWL)
Peak position: 10
Italian star Sabrina’s debut for SAW’s PWL label. By this point she had already had a huge international hit with “Boys (Summertime Love)” and been ogled over by Jonathan Ross on “The Last Resort”, but her career in the UK faded quite rapidly.
“All Of Me” was her last (minor) chart hit here and is chirpy enough, but Sabrina’s voice is buried under an unforgiving stack of electronics and the chorus never really punches home. It has plenty of energy but leaves you with little to remember it by.
21. Nuclear Assault - Fight To Be Free (Under One Flag)
Peak position: 21
23. Robert Lloyd and the New Four Seasons - Nothing Matters (In Tape)
Peak position: 13
Largely forgotten Robert Lloyd single which dispensed with the last scraps of post-punk and fully immersed itself in eighties pop and tight suits. Smooth, and one of the most conventionally crafted records released in the eighties by a post-punk figure, “Nothing Matters” is well produced, but lacks enough of a hook to succeed on pop terms, while having none of the edge necessary to excite Nightingales fans.
Peak position: 21
23. Robert Lloyd and the New Four Seasons - Nothing Matters (In Tape)
Peak position: 13
Largely forgotten Robert Lloyd single which dispensed with the last scraps of post-punk and fully immersed itself in eighties pop and tight suits. Smooth, and one of the most conventionally crafted records released in the eighties by a post-punk figure, “Nothing Matters” is well produced, but lacks enough of a hook to succeed on pop terms, while having none of the edge necessary to excite Nightingales fans.
The lyrics were written about the woman he was dating who subsequently went on to become his wife, though, so every inch of that joyous chorus is meant. Perhaps sometimes the angular guitar lines just aren't necessary.
24. Highliners - Henry The Wasp (ABC)
Peak position: 12
27. Phase II - Reachin' (Republic)
Peak position: 27
A Hacienda classic which evokes fond memories of the Summer of 88 for many, Phase II also pointed out where pop music was headed – the cult classic of that year showcasing the rhythms, basslines and grooves of the slickest chart movers of 1989. Not a single stroke of it sounds underground now, but its epic optimism remains something to behold.
For the complete charts, please go to the UKMix Forum
Number Ones In The National Charts
U2 - "Desire" (Island)
Whitney Houston - "One Moment In Time" (Arista)
Enya - "Orinoco Flow" (WEA)
No comments:
Post a Comment