Showing posts with label Phuture Phantasy Club. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Phuture Phantasy Club. Show all posts

Sunday, November 22, 2026

125. Wedding Present - Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now? (Reception)




Four weeks at number one from 4th October 1988


The first woman I fell in love with (or at least, the first woman I thought I loved) was cursed with the communication skills of a jellyfish*. This is an admittedly harsh way of putting it, so I should take this opportunity to gently clarify the facts; her prime motivations in life, so far as I could initially tell, were to be kind, amenable and liked by as many people as possible. It was adorable when we were friends, and a big part of the reason why I became besotted with her. If you were aiming to be in a relationship with her, however, things were tough, because all was not as it immediately seemed. 

Everybody has been out with somebody like this at one point or another; the smiley, quiet, graceful people pleaser who to your amazement, moodily tells you two months after a date (and not before) that actually, it was a drag, and they were only coming along to make you happy, or actually, you should have known from the fact that their smile was 2% tighter than normal that they didn’t enjoy spending time with your friend and his partner a month ago, so you shouldn’t have arranged it again. On one occasion, very close to the point before she dumped me, I found myself saying “You should have told me. I don’t understand why you didn’t TELL me!” To my shame, I realised a few minutes later that I was just quoting this song (and that alone should have been reason enough to get the boot).

Whatever you think of David Gedge’s work, he has an almost comedically astute sense for the dynamics of failing relationships; had he not made a modest success of being an indie star, I have to wonder whether he might have been able to move into relationship counselling instead. “Why Are You Being So Reasonable Now” has less of a narrative than their previous indie number ones, and almost feels like a series of spiky mid-argument complaints, barked and left to hang in the air. “Do I have to guess how you're going to feel each day” competes with “No one can change that much in three days” and “You've never mentioned this before”, all high in the chart of “exasperated lines we’ve all used in real life when our relationships are struggling”.

The final line, repeated incessantly, is so hilarious it could almost have been written for a Half Man Half Biscuit song. After the song’s title is repeated for the final time, Gedge moans “Oh… how could you do this to me?” If you’re in the middle of a break-up, somebody’s meek reasonableness can feel like the biggest punishment of all – all those months of agony and sniping comments about failed mind-reading peaking with the dumpee putting on their gentle, kindly face again; the face you fell for to begin with. As it all began, so it must cruelly end. In certain circumstances, reasonableness can feel like the hottest knife of all.

This single ended up becoming a popular favourite with fans, reaching number 8 in John Peel’s Festive Fifty that year, and has persistently received favourable comments online. Despite this, and despite my feelings on how relatable the subject matter is, I’m afraid it’s not something I want to hear very often. Melodically speaking, there’s a serious lack of either hooks or lingering tension in this one. The Weddoes are at their absolute best when they come up with an aggressive, stabbing riff (“Brassneck”, “Anyone Can Make A Mistake”) an almost poppy chorus (“Nobody’s Twisting Your Arm”) or a soaring, repetitive finale (“Kennedy”, “My Favourite Dress”). “Reasonable” just sulkily kicks along, spraying leaves in the middle of the path and never truly finding any jewels beneath them. It’s relatively memorable, but also somewhat middling and muted; never truly growing teeth or tickling neglected parts of your brain with its melodies.

As such, I don’t pull it out to play very often, but for those who love back-catalogue curios, it’s of worth for two reasons – firstly, it was a stand-alone single which never found any place on a subsequent studio album. Secondly, a French language version was released (“Pourquoi Es Tu Devenue Si Raisonnable?”) which treats listeners to Gedge barking the song with his Yorkshire accent partially intact. God alone knows what the French fans made of it – the one fluent French-speaking friend I had at the time informed me that it was “hilariously bad”.